SearchRecent EntriesNOBODY ASKED ME BUT...NOBODY ASKED ME BUT... NOBODY ASKED ME BUT... NOBODY ASKED ME BUT... NOBODY ASKED ME BUT... NOBODY ASKED ME BUT... NOBODY ASKED ME BUT... NOBODY ASKED ME BUT... NOBODY ASKED ME BUT... NOBODY ASKED ME BUT... ArchivesCategory:Baseball Culture History Media Middle East Miscellaneous Movie/Theater Reviews Politics Sports THE NEW YORK TIMES War Monthly: January 2009 December 2008 November 2008 September 2008 August 2008 July 2008 April 2008 March 2008 February 2008 January 2008 December 2007 November 2007 October 2007 September 2007 August 2007 July 2007 June 2007 May 2007 April 2007 March 2007 February 2007 January 2007 December 2006 November 2006 October 2006 September 2006 August 2006 July 2006 June 2006 May 2006 April 2006 March 2006 February 2006 January 2006 December 2005 November 2005 October 2005 September 2005 August 2005 July 2005 June 2005 May 2005 April 2005 March 2005 February 2005 January 2005 December 2004 November 2004 October 2004 September 2004 August 2004 July 2004 June 2004 May 2004 April 2004 March 2004 February 2004 January 2004 Old Horsefeathers Archives |
March 08, 2006VANITY OF HUMAN WISHES: THE CASE OF BARRY BONDS        Horsefeathers has lamented the decline of quality in American popular culture. We wonder what the ghosts of Jo Stafford and Frank Sinatra would have to say about this year's Oscar winning song, a ghastly assault on the senses, depicting the hard life of a pimp. This decline has been evident in other spheres as well: one that particularly bothers Horsefeathers is the quality of newspaper sports writing. We long ago ceased reading the New York Times sports pages because the writing had less to do with sports than with politically correct social agendas. The writers seem aggrieved affirmative action hires, determined to hit the reader over the head with the racist, sexist horrors of sport. When the New York Sun began to compete with the Times, we turned with trepidation to the sports pages. We were amazed to find writers who are knowledgable about the sports they cover, and interested in the actual games played and their role as entertainment. Today's issue has a special treat: two articles by Tim Marchman. One about Kirby Pucket's death and one about Barry Bonds's drug use. Marchman is unusual in that he possesses the factual knowledge of a good journalist, plus the gift of character evocation of a novelist---which he is. He deftly explores the motivations that drove each man, their demons as well as their talent. For Barry Bonds, it wasn't enough to be one of the 10 greatest players of all time; he had to be the greatest, and the drugs made him just that. That is the essence of the steroids scandal, and why Bonds's story resonates so much more than those of less gifted but equally guilty players. Ultimately, the simultaneously grandiose and prosaic answers (to oversimplify, it's in the nature of greats to never be satisfied) are probably best dealt with by a different kind of writer than Fainaru-Wada or Williams         While we're waiting for that future artist's work, we can turn to Dr. Johnson who many years ago explored the motivation of individuals like Bonds. An all consuming "Ambition to be great", hubris, leads inevitably to downfall. As Johnson put it in his magnificent poem, The Vanity of Human Wishes: ...From every Room descends the painted Face, ...The Form distorted justifies the Fall,         Barry Bonds's fate has already been determined. Now its just a question of how far he will fall. << Back to Horsefeathers |
Favorite LinksPajamas MediaMiddle East Strategy at Harvard Politics Central Michael Yon Victor Hanson Mideast Outpost Captain's Quarters ChicagoBoyz Faultline USA SteveForPrez Democracy Project Iowahawk Instapundit News Forum Hotair Real Clear Politics Counterterrorism Blog Ace of Spades Contentions Mark Steyn Bookworm Gateway Pundit PoliPundit Transatlantic Intelligencer Sisu Villainous Company Bill Whittle Eye on the UN Armavirunque Cox & Forkum Michelle Malkin Baseball Crank Terry Teachout No Pasaran Power Line Hugh Hewitt Jihad Watch Kim du Toit Dhimmi Watch Steven Plaut Belmont Club Scott Burgess The Anti-Idiotarian Insomnomaniac Politburo Diktat Iraq the Model Roger Simon Mediacrity Shrinkwrapped Neo-neocon American Thinker New English Review Baseball Musings Eternity Road Heretical Ideas The Iconoclast Intellectual Conservative Vodkapundit The Corner Davids Medienkritik Samizdata Volokh Conspiracy Dinocrat Scott Ott Milt's File Daily Pundit ExtrasSyndicate this site (XML)Powered by Movable Type 3.11 |
Comments
Everytime I tried to like Barry Bonds, he did something to piss me off. In spite of this, I thought he was a great hitter. He may have broken Ruth's and Aaron's records without the steroids--the home runs would only have reached the right field stands instead of McCovey Cove. What a tragedy.
By the way, Roger Kahn recounted how an editor once helped him refine his sportswriting by showing him a sentence from the archives: ". . . he pitched as if the plate were high and outside."
Posted by: Mark_Belt
at March 8, 2006 11:15 AM
The sad thing about ballplayers (like actors) is that we think we know them. We don't know squat about them. As for Bonds' many apologists (like the S.F. Giants fan at my work place) I want to ask "where will you be 12 years from now when he is either broken up, crippled or God forbid dead"?
Posted by: Ripper
at March 8, 2006 12:49 PM
Role Models,
If there are more professional Artists than professional Athletes, why then do we drug test athletic students and not artistic students? If more children grow up to be teachers than sports stars, why aren’t college professors in line with Rickey (Running Back) Williams proving their clarity of mind through drug testing? This looks more like revenge of the nerds than a war on drugs to me. It is a war on Jocks. Or war on the athletic kid that broke an intellectuals’ glasses in 4th grade. Michael Moore can try to influence an election by creating hate and mistrust by using snippets of artistic film and sound bites, while college professors across America regurgitate Moore’s brilliance to our future leaders. But who cares that these influential pot-heads mold the minds of the impressionable. If Mary K Letourneau had been randomly tested like Rickey, she may not have got knocked up by a 6th grader. An Overland Co 10th Grade geography teacher was just recorded for 20 minutes ranting about Bush being like Hitler, Terrorist being justified hitting the Towers and the American flag looking like the Nazi flag. One heck of a role model there, I tell you. And yes we all know there are 100 Lawyers for every guy who can hit a 90 mile an hour fastball.
If I want to save a baby Fur Seal, I will ask Barry Bonds how to do it, because animal activists and Green Peace are not tested. Barry gets the bat through the zone so fast he could send that pup skinned and into the skiff with one whack. Yes I know I just offended Yoko Ono but she and Snoop Dog are on the same drug test policy. Artistic Freedom is equal to overlooking the fact Van Gogh is put on a pedestal because he drank absinth (a liquid hallucinogen) cut his ear off and sent it UPS. Hello education system, are we still teaching his greatness to the impressionable.
Every parent has the right to implement a drug policy under their own roof. Socialism believes in the institution parenting, whether you believe in the deflective mantra of Youth-Problem or not. In the 50’s the deflective term was the Beat-Nicks and 60’s it was the Hippies. The 70’s, corporate Yuppies did more Coke than all the High schools in our nation. I happen to think it is an adult problem that trickles down to our youth. When we send the message through a public school system that student athletes need to be drug tested? Are we saying those students can’t be trusted, or are we saying they are the only ones worth saving? You-Pick, and then justify it to yourself.
If Student Athletes stood outside the school and chanted (to Yoko’s favorite tune) All We Are Saaaaaayyyyyying (is) Let’s Watch You Go Pe-Peeeeee! Would Michael Moore love them or accuse them of being Bush’s minions. Revenge of the Nerds I tell you, until then, if you want Higher Standards? Send your daughter to an NFL locker room, not Berkley!!!! Rickey Williams should grade test papers, if he wants freedom from testing.
The next college professor that stands before a class and says our enemy is the freedom fighter and Bush the dictator? I would hope that George Bush would bust into the class room, hook up a set of jumper cables to the “knowledgeable ones” Gonads and say; “Pardon me Ho-Chi-Men, but the Dictator is in the house”, just to prove that teacher right for once. The day news annalist, pundits, entertainment industry and news paper employees are drug tested is the day a real drug education begins. Either bring drug testing on strong, or get it out of here completely. Hollywood can go smoke another bowl, and influence this nation.
I think if Pete Rose was a 1st grader today? He would be medicated for his hyperactivity, he would bore of T-Ball because keeping score hurts feelings, and he would never grow up to hit more baseballs than any man alive or dead.
If Charles Barkley said “ I am not a role model, parents are” And a Oscar winner said “ The Arts are a Hammer that molds society” Never expect me to think we are drug testing the appropriate Sub Group of human-society. Revenge of the Nerds, has provided rights to them selves that do not apply to large, aggressive, fast men. America hides its drug use well by pointing fingers at Jocks is all?
Posted by: akabaseball
at March 9, 2006 12:02 PM
Post a comment
Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)
(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)